Lessons in Storytelling From Doctor Who

The Eleventh Doctor and Amy Pond

The Eleventh Doctor and Amy Pond (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

I recently reactivated my Netflix account (getting another month free service) for the purpose of watching the BBC series Doctor Who. On one practical level this was a mistake. I started, and could not stop watching. I’ve fallen behind in a number of commitments, and haven’t done much work the past week on my new novel, Refuge. But now that I’ve come up for air (sometime in the middle of Season 5), I realize there are some wonderful lessons in how to tell a story available from the tales of the Doctor and his companions.

For those not familiar with it, Doctor Who is the wonderfully quirky BBC science fiction series about a time-traveling immortal alien. It originally aired from 1963 to 1989, and was revived in 2005. I’ve been watching only the new series; I may or may not try to find the original one. It features a main character called the Doctor. The Doctor is a Time Lord, a member of an alien race who travel about in time and space, are sensitive to any anomalies in time, have some limited telepathic abilities, possess incredibly encyclopedic scientific and historical knowledge, and potentially live forever. When the Doctor is mortally injured, he can regenerate and heal himself, taking on a new body in the process. (That last is of course a device used to incorporate new actors in the leading role seamlessly, but it works well.) He travels about in a time-space machine called the TARDIS (Time And Relative Dimension In Space), which is good sized on the inside but on the outside looks like a British police phone box from the 1960s.

The Doctor is obsessed with humanity. (Especially with the British. Go figure.) The reason for his obsession is never explicitly stated, but we may easily deduce it from the fact that he has lost his entire species, along with the fact that humans strongly resemble the Time Lords in appearance and in some aspects of behavior. (Amy Pond: “But you look human!” The Doctor: “No, you look Time Lord. We came first.”) The series goes all over the place in space and time, but the Doctor does spend an abnormally high percentage of his efforts saving humanity. The Doctor is terribly lonely, and finds companionship mainly among humans.

That will do for an introduction. Now, let’s consider what we may learn as storytellers from the longest-running science-fiction television series of all time.

There is no such thing as too much danger.

In every episode, the Doctor, his companion, others under his protection, the human race and the planet earth, the universe, all of the universes, or up to all of the above are in mortal danger. (Rose Tyler: “Is it always this dangerous?” The Doctor (grinning happily): “Yes!”) The Doctor is a formidable figure, feared by mighty conquering races and demonic entities, yet he always seems to be in a horrible predicament and never in the series waltzes in and shrugs off the flea-bite threats of mere mortals.

Trouble and danger, danger and trouble: these are keys to storytelling. You can’t have too much of them. Put your main characters in mortal danger, make them suffer and fear, give them challenges that seem completely impossible. Your readers will not be frightened away, and in most cases they will readily suspend disbelief when your characters manage to overcome the danger after all (as they must, even when they sacrifice themselves in the end to do it). If you make the danger believable, if you get the heart racing and the adrenaline pumping, belief will follow.

Toning down the danger and challenges facing the characters for the sake of believability or of not scaring off readers is a common failing of beginning writers. It has been one of mine at times.

Creative solutions are more interesting.

The Doctor almost never carries a weapon. The only device he routinely carries with him is a tool called a “sonic screwdriver,” which is handy for opening and sealing doors, fiddling with computers and other devices, breaking ropes and chains, and similar uses. Confronted with terrible obstacles and impossible challenges, he improvises solutions from his amazing store of knowledge and what’s available, and even then the line of the plot is seldom straightforward.

This makes for a much better story. The protagonist must be faced with challenges that are outside his experience and which he cannot solve using solely the tools in his inventory. The reader should be puzzled, not seeing how the problem can be solved until the story presents it to them, or at least not easily. Simple and straightforward equal predictable equals a dull story.

One need not go to the extremes of Doctor Who and few plot situations allow for that level of lunacy, but when in doubt, make it trickier.

Passion makes a character appealing.

The Doctor is an immortal character of immense age and vast knowledge, but he is far from a robot. He feels deeply and intensely about so many things: the destruction of his home world and of the Time Lords, the Daleks who were responsible for that, the human race, the people under his care, and above all his companions. Although he maintains a jaunty and sometimes preposterous demeanor, the passion underlying this exterior reveals itself frequently. (To Rose Tyler: “I could save the world but lose you.”)

Your main characters should never be wooden, passionless, highly efficient creatures. They must love, hate, desire, fear, burn with fury and ache with loss. This is what will make your readers identify with them and care about them; that which does not feel evokes no compassion or empathy.

Sexual tension makes great character interaction.

The Doctor’s companions (in the new series) are always young women of extraordinary courage, resourcefulness, and strength of will. With one exception, they are also always highly attractive young women. The Doctor himself is always a bit goofy-looking even in his handsomer incarnations, but he is mysterious and impressive enough to draw desire even so. Yet the Doctor never, never has sex with any companion.

One might plausibly suppose that the Doctor, being an alien despite his appearance, is not attracted to human females, but that isn’t the case. If it were, why would he invite one hot young babe after another to join him on his adventures? Also, one may see the suppressed desire in him on the rare occasions when the Doctor has kissed a companion. There is always an ostensible practical reason for the kiss (such as the kiss given to Rose Tyler at the end of the first season when he absorbed the TARDIS energy from her to save her life, or the one given to Martha Jones shortly after they first met to give her some alien DNA that would show up in a scan reading), but the Doctor could have achieved these purposes in some other way and the passion in the kisses is obvious.

The reason the Doctor avoids sex with his companions is because he is immortal and they are not. (The Doctor: “I’m 907 years old and I never age, I just change. This could never work out.” Amy Pond: “I wasn’t thinking of anything that long-term.”) He would like to have his companion as a lover (most of the time), and she would like that, too, but he can’t. And he isn’t the type not to think long-term.

Whatever the reason for it, though, sexual tension is a great thing to have between two characters. It draws them together and animates their interactions in a way that few other things can. It lends intensity and passion to everything else they do together. If you find two characters drawn to each other sexually, think carefully before you have them give in and consummate that desire. This will change the nature of their interaction completely, and make for a different story.

One final lesson is that yours truly is pretty damned creative in finding justification for obsessive behavior. I’m rather proud of myself. 🙂



Filed under Fantasy Storytelling

7 responses to “Lessons in Storytelling From Doctor Who

  1. I only recently got into Doctor Who as well so I can probably relate to just how addictive the show is. There’s just something inherently appealing about being able to travel with the Doctor. It’s escapism at its finest as it doesn’t just introduce us to a fictional world; it gives us a fictional world with multiple settings and a huge cast of fresh characters almost every episode. It’s just such a nice show 😀

  2. I’m a Doctor Who noob too, but love what I’ve seen so far. I’ve only seen about five episodes of the Amy Pond part of the series…sometimes involving lots of confusion since it seemed to be final episodes in the last Amy Pond part.

    Back on topic. Despite my noobness, I liked how you connected it to better storytelling and they are all things I’d like to keep in mind on my own writing projects as I probably struggle a bit much with sacrificing danger and excitement for believability.

    I shared your post to my facebook 🙂

  3. Thanks for commenting, both of you. And thanks for sharing, Saronai!
    I found moving from Season 4 to Season 5, which is when Amy Pond shows up, a little jarring. The first four seasons had a consistent and growing cast of minor characters: Rose Tyler, her mother, her boyfriend, Captain Jack, Martha Jones and her family, Donna Noble and HER family, Sarah Jane Smith, and so on. At the end of the last episode of Season 4, when the 10th Doctor (David Tennant) knows he’s going to regenerate, he goes around doing good deeds and essentially saying goodbye — and then in the new season every one of those characters is gone. Except for the Doctor himself and River Song, no one is left from the first four seasons.

  4. I’m admittedly nervous about it, but I credit you with the danger I infused episode 5 of my blog series with ( http://musesings.wordpress.com/2013/03/29/silent-rain-5-the-nightmare/ ). My 11-year-old liked it and found it really scary, so there’s that.

    Either way, your words in this post got me thinking on the blog series I’ve been working on. Until then I was ushering the main character to the safety of the inner sanctum of her family home, under her mother’s orders, during a war.

    I was gonna do what made sense for the characters involved (mom wanted to protect her heir, and her daughter is not in the habit of disobedience). I tried hard for that quality of danger so thick you wonder how they’re going to escape it.

    Thing is, I never would have gone about thinking on how to endanger the characters in this episode without breaking the story or out of character actions until I read this timely post of yours 😀

    Even if my attempt could be better, I still love how you helped activate it as this fits really well into character backgrounds, story progression, and helped me make the main character a little more active than she’s been so far. In short, there were things that needed to/were going to happen and this idea of danger your wrote helped my brain work out far better than simply mentioning the events as background drops or something more mundane.

    Long comment short: Thanks…episode 5 is pretty much dedicated to you 😀

  5. Reblogged this on Saronai's Blog and commented:
    Loved or hated it, the level of danger I shoved into episode 5 is dedicated to Brian Rush and this post. If I hadn’t read it last week, I never would have set my brain to the task of endangering a character retreating obediently to the safety of an inner sanctum. I’m afraid the result might have been more mundane and “reasonable” action.

    Instead, my thoughts dwelled on this and how I could try it without breaking characters or story to accomplish it.

    Thanks Brian, though the result may not live up to Dr. Who standards, I never would have tried for danger this early in the blog series and I’m afraid this post may have been far more uneventful otherwise.

  6. Just reblogged this post of yours and made the dedication official 😀

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s